20 Mistakes Almost Every Beginner Makes When Tasting Cheese

20 Mistakes Almost Every Beginner Makes When Tasting Cheese

Anyone can learn how to taste cheese.

But almost everyone begins by making the same mistakes.

That is perfectly normal.

We may learn how to taste wine, coffee, or even chocolate, yet very few people have ever received a genuine introduction to cheese tasting.

For more than 115 years, Androuet Master Cheesemongers have observed the habits of thousands of customers and workshop participants. Over time, the same mistakes appear again and again.

The good news is that they are very easy to correct.

1. Tasting Cheese Straight from the Refrigerator

This is probably the most common mistake.

Cold temperatures harden the fat and mute a large part of the cheese’s aroma.

A cheese tasted at 4°C often seems firmer, less fragrant, and less complex than it truly is.

Depending on the family, it is usually best to remove cheese from the refrigerator 30 minutes to one hour before serving. Larger pieces may need even longer.

“A cheese served too cold is like a concert with half the sound turned off.”

— Nicolas, Androuet Master Cheesemonger

2. Looking Only at the Name

Many people assume that a cheese’s name tells them everything they need to know.

Yet two Comtés, two Camemberts, or two Saint-Nectaires can taste remarkably different.

The producer, the season, the milk, and above all the affinage all have a profound influence on the final result.

The name is a starting point, never a guarantee.

3. Forgetting to Observe the Cheese

Tasting begins with the eyes.

The color of the rind, the appearance of the paste, its flexibility, and the presence of openings already provide valuable information.

Master Cheesemongers always observe before they taste.

4. Failing to Smell the Cheese

The sense of smell plays a major role in how we perceive flavor.

Yet many people go straight to tasting.

Taking a few seconds to smell the cheese can already reveal its main aromatic families.

5. Tasting Too Quickly

Cheese evolves in the mouth.

The first few seconds tell only part of the story.

Allow it to melt slowly.

Breathe.

Notice how it changes.

The finest aromas often appear only after a few moments.

6. Starting with the Strongest Cheeses

If you taste Roquefort before Brie de Meaux, the Brie may seem far more muted than it really is.

A tasting should generally progress from the most delicate cheeses to the most intense:

  • fresh cheeses;
  • mild and delicate cheeses;
  • soft-ripened cheeses;
  • pressed cheeses;
  • more powerful varieties;
  • blue cheeses at the end.

This order preserves the sensitivity of the palate.

7. Assuming That a Strong Smell Means a Strong Flavor

Some washed-rind cheeses have an impressively powerful aroma.

Yet their flavor can be surprisingly delicate.

Conversely, cheeses that smell relatively mild may reveal remarkable complexity on the palate.

Never judge a cheese by aroma alone.

8. Believing That Older Always Means Better

Age is not everything.

Every cheese has an ideal tasting window.

Before that moment, it may lack expression.

Afterwards, it may begin to lose its balance.

The role of the Master Cheesemonger is precisely to identify that moment.

“Our profession is less about selling cheese than choosing the right day to offer it.”

— Claire, Androuet Master Cheesemonger

9. Deciding That You Dislike an Entire Cheese Family

“I don’t like goat’s cheese.”

“I don’t like blue cheese.”

“I don’t like washed rinds.”

We hear these phrases very often.

In reality, every family contains an extraordinary range of textures, intensities, and aromatic profiles.

During our workshops, participants regularly discover a new favorite in a category they thought they disliked.

10. Serving Every Cheese at the Same Temperature

A fresh cheese, a 30-month Comté, and an Époisses do not respond in exactly the same way to temperature.

Serving temperature has a major effect on texture and aroma.

It may seem like a small detail, but it can transform the tasting.

11. Using One Knife for the Entire Cheese Board

Cutting a blue cheese and then using the same knife on a goat’s cheese without cleaning it can alter both flavor and appearance.

During professional tastings, knives are cleaned regularly to preserve the identity of each cheese.

12. Automatically Removing Every Rind

Some rinds are entirely edible and contribute fully to the character of the cheese.

Others are primarily technical or protective.

Learning to distinguish between them is one of the useful skills taught during our workshops.

13. Cutting Cheese at Random

The way a cheese is cut is never insignificant.

The aim is to give every guest a balanced proportion of rind and interior paste.

Poor cutting can deprive some people of an essential part of the experience.

14. Trying to Detect Exactly the Same Aromas as Everyone Else

Tasting is a personal experience.

Two people may perceive different nuances in the same cheese.

Neither is necessarily wrong.

Vocabulary helps us share sensations. It should never be used to impose one single truth.

15. Overlooking Pairings

Cheese does not pair only with red wine.

Depending on the cheese, white wine, cider, craft beer, tea, or Champagne may reveal far more of its personality.

Exploring pairings is one of the great pleasures of tasting.

16. Buying Only Cheeses You Already Know

Curiosity is the best way to improve.

Every new discovery enriches your tasting memory and helps refine your preferences.

17. Assuming a Cheese Tastes the Same All Year

Cheese is a living product.

The season influences:

  • the milk;
  • the animals’ diet;
  • production;
  • affinage.

The same cheese tasted in spring and winter may offer very different profiles.

18. Forgetting the Work of the Affineur

Producers are often discussed, while affineurs receive far less attention.

Yet much of a cheese’s personality develops during maturation.

Temperature, humidity, turning, brushing, and care of the rind all shape the final result.

19. Looking Only for the Most Powerful Cheeses

Intensity is not a measure of quality.

The greatest cheeses are often those with the finest balance.

Finesse, length, harmony, and complexity matter far more than sheer power.

20. Believing You Need to Be an Expert

This may be the greatest mistake of all.

The best tasters are not necessarily those who know the greatest number of names.

They are the people who take time to observe, compare, and remain curious.

Tasting is a skill that develops gradually.

Like any passion.

A Story from an Androuet Workshop

At the beginning of many workshops, we ask participants which cheeses they believe they do not like.

The answers are often the same:

Blue cheeses, highly matured goat’s cheeses, and washed-rind cheeses.

By the end of the session, those same cheeses frequently appear among their favorites.

Why?

Because they have been tasted at the right moment, in the right order, and with the explanations needed to understand them.

This perfectly captures the philosophy of Androuet workshops:

The aim is not to persuade, but to help people discover.

The Best Way to Learn Is to Practice

Reading advice is useful.

Applying it is what truly changes the tasting experience.

By simply developing the habit of observing a cheese, smelling it, respecting its serving temperature, tasting it slowly, and comparing your sensations, you will make rapid progress.

That is exactly what Androuet workshops are designed to encourage.

For more than 115 years, our Master Cheesemongers have passed on these simple gestures that permanently change the way people experience cheese.

Because learning to avoid the most common mistakes is already the first step toward tasting like a professional.

Learn More

A – The Complete Guide to Cheese Workshops

  1. Introduction to The Complete Guide to Cheese Workshops
  2. What Is a Cheese Workshop?
  3. What Happens During a Cheese Workshop?
  4. The Tasting Methods Used by Master Cheesemongers
  5. The Complete Vocabulary of Cheese Tasting
  6. How to Recognize Every Cheese Family ?
  7. The 20 Mistakes Almost Every Beginner Makes When Tasting Cheese
  8. The Equipment Used During a Cheese Workshop
  9. The Role of the Master Cheesemonger During a Tasting
  10. How to Continue Learning After Your First Workshop ?
  11. Cheese Workshop FAQ — Part 1
  12. Cheese Workshop FAQ — Part 2
  13. Conclusion

B – Androuet: Paris’s Cheese Workshop Expert

C – Cheese Workshop Experiences in Paris

Learn & federate

70€/pers

“Cheese discovery” workshop in Paris

Come and learn the subtle art of cheese and its pairings with our cheesemonger and affineur—an expert in the science of cheese.

95€/pers

“Cheese enthusiast” workshop in Paris

Deepen your knowledge with this workshop on cheese and wine pairings.

76€/pers

Cheese-making workshop in Paris

Learn how to make 3 cheeses.

79€/pers

The “Secrets of Cheese” workshop in Paris

Learn, taste, and have fun. Come and discover this introduction to the art of cheese tasting. Learn to put your sensory impressions into words—all in a fun and cheerful atmosphere!
An Androuet exclusive.